A study published October 13 in Optics Express reports a result that runs against conventional specification practice: a custom-mixed LED spectrum rated only 80 CRI helped people in their 70s and 80s sort colors more accurately than a daylight reference rated 97.
The low score was not the point, the authors argue. The spectrum was tuned for eyes that have aged.
Why standard metrics miss the problem
The eye's lens yellows with age and filters out short-wavelength light. Ra and TM-30, the color metrics specifiers actually use, are calculated with a fixed standard observer that makes no allowance for lens aging, even though the CIE's own 2006 physiological model includes an age parameter. The work comes from Fudan University in Shanghai, with two Opple Lighting employees among its eight authors.
How the spectra were built
The team modeled the color response of aging eyes and derived two metrics: one estimating how much lost color discrimination a spectrum recovers for an older viewer, the other measuring color fidelity against a 32-year-old's perception. It screened 11,541 candidate spectra from a 16-channel LED luminaire, all at 5000 K with Ra of at least 80.
Two candidates were tested against a simulated D50 daylight reference with Ra of 97. P1 prioritized color discrimination at Ra 80; P2 balanced discrimination and fidelity at Ra 90. When the authors re-ranked every candidate using the conventional standard observer, P1 lost its top position. The spec-sheet favorite and the aging eye's favorite can be different lights.
What the viewing test showed
Participants aged 70 and older, with a mean age of 81.7, sorted colored caps from the Farnsworth-Munsell 100 Hue test in a viewing booth at 300 lux. Mean error scores fell from 79.2 under the reference to 62.4 under P1 and 65.0 under P2, and both drops were statistically significant. Color discrimination improved for 26 of 34 participants (76.5%) under P1 and 22 of 34 (64.7%) under P2. The gap between the two optimized spectra was not significant.
Asked whether fruits and vegetables looked natural, 28 participants said yes under P1, compared with 26 under both the reference and P2. A two-person difference proves little, but it suggests the lower Ra cost P1 nothing in perceived naturalness.
Caveats and commercial context
The authors set out several limits on what the trial can support:
- The sample was small, and people with advanced cataracts, glaucoma or macular degeneration were excluded, which removes many of the residents a memory-care designer lights for.
- Chromaticity between the reference and test lights was not perfectly matched, and the naturalness question was a simple yes or no.
- The authors warn against reading 300 lux as a recommendation.
- The underlying data is available only on request, so independent replication matters.
Opple financially supported the study, according to the paper's disclosures. The paper names no product, but a news release distributed through Optica, the journal's publisher, says Opple is now working to translate the findings into lighting products. That makes this early product development as much as academic research.
The method also requires at least four independently controlled LED channels. Multichannel color-mixing fixtures rarely appear in a care-facility bid, and most products sold as tunable in healthcare and senior living adjust color temperature across two channels, which would not reproduce these spectra. That gap is an observation added by the original article, not a claim in the paper.
For lighting people in senior living and healthcare, the study raises a pointed question. The industry's color metrics make no allowance for aging eyes, and a growing share of building occupants are well past middle age. If a tuned spectrum can help residents read a medication label or judge whether food has spoiled, the debate shifts to how quickly that evidence reaches specifications and product lines, and whose products get there first.
